Margit Tonson

Film critic

Estonia

Voted in the critics’ poll

Voted for

Breaking the Waves	1996	Lars von Trier
Breathless	1960	Jean-Luc Godard
Fear Eats the Soul	1974	Rainer Werner Fassbinder
Hidden	2004	Michael Haneke
Mirror	1974	Andrei Tarkovsky
Mulholland Dr	2001	David Lynch
Persona	1966	Ingmar Bergman
Ukuaru		Leida Laius
Vertigo	1958	Alfred Hitchcock
Woman Under the Influence, A	1974	John Cassavetes

Comments

For me, greatest films always have to speak to me or challenge me not only on an intellectual, conscious level, but also by somehow accessing my subconsciousness as well. This ability to access one’s subconscious mind is a prerequisite of change – changing the viewer’s point of view, his/her state of mind, disproving one’s prejudice, opening his/her eyes etc. The greatest films all do that: they have the power to change things, and as a film theorist and critic one can spend hundreds of challenging, yet rewarding hours trying to discover how exactly this change was conducted and executed. As you probably already noticed, there is one Estonian film on the list as well (surely, at the time it was made, Ukuaru was considered part of the Soviet film tradition). It shouldn’t come as a surprise for Sight & Sound readers, but I am pretty sure it does. Leida Laius studied in Moscow with Otar Iosseliani, Larisa Shepitko and lots of other significant Soviet filmmakers, and was taught by Gerassimov, Romm, Kuleshov, Dovzhenko and so on. Excellent melodrama, wonderful acting and smart editing go hand in hand with Arvo Pärt’s original score, which includes the famous ‘Ukuaru Waltz’, to make Ukuaru one the greatest Estonian films of all time.