Film editor and critic, Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung
Germany
Voted in the critics’ poll
Voted for
2004 |
Wong Kar Wai |
|
1974 |
Roman Polanski |
|
1977 |
Michael Cimino |
|
1995 |
Michael Mann |
|
1924 |
F. W. Murnau |
|
1973 |
Jean Eustache |
|
1963 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
|
1974 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
|
1956 |
John Ford |
|
1950 |
Billy Wilder |
Comments
Needless to say that my list would have looked different last year and might even look different next month. Though I don’t mistake my favourites for the greatest films ever, there’s too big a lack of mandatory criteria as to which films should be in the pantheon to care for that demon called objectivity. So I tried to find a delicate balance betweeen les films de ma vie and films whose merits and achievements in the history of cinema can hardly be denied – with a slight penchant for films with a personal impact.